Suicidal Caterpillar Infested with Tachinid Flies

2012 October 27

I thought this one would be a good lead-up to halloween, for reasons that will become obvious.
I spotted this caterpillar on June 4, 2012 in an odd location: it was on a rock in the little stream that runs beside the road we live on, with its head immersed in the water. It looked for all the world as if it was trying to drown itself. It had an oddly bloated, sausage-like appearance, but wasn’t completely dead, so I brought it home to see what was going on with it.

I admit that a big part of my reason for bringing it home, was that I suspected that it might not be what it seems. See, I have this hypothesis that caterpillars that are out-of-place and doing things that appear suicidally dangerous, really are trying to kill themselves[1]. What’s more, I suspect that a big reason why they would be doing this, is because they are fatally infected with a parasite. And even though it is too late to save themselves, if they can get themselves killed they can keep their parasites from hatching, and so save their nieces and nephews and cousins from getting attacked and infected by them later.

I originally thought that the white objects glued to the front of its body were the parasites, but it turned out they weren’t[2]. They never did anything other than hang around. I don’t know what they were.

It lived for some days, but didn’t act as if it were well. It refused to eat any leaves that I gave it, and barely moved. Finally, one day it died, and on June 9 these maggots cut a hole in its side and crawled out

Two of the maggots came out right away, and a third just stayed inside with its head(?)[3] poking out. At this point, the caterpillar looked pretty much deflated.

I put the maggots into a jar with a moist paper towel, and they promptly made pupae like this one.

that hatched out to produce these flies on June 22. They looked a lot like a standard housefly, except they were only maybe 2/3 as long as a housefly.

This is one of the hundreds of species of tachnid flies. I think I can narrow it down to one of the “red-tailed tachnid flies” in the genus Winthemia. Partly based on the reddish tip of its abdomen, and partly because it is apparently the most common genus of tachnid flies in North America. And they parasitize armyworm and cutworm caterpillars, which these appear to have been doing.

[1] Behaviors that I consider signs that a caterpillar is trying to get itself killed: (a) normally well-camouflaged caterpillars that have moved to a place where their camouflage doesn’t work, as if they are begging to be eaten; (b) caterpillars eating toxic plants that aren’t listed as being among their normal foodplants; (c) crawling someplace where they are likely to either get drowned, or dried out and cooked by direct sunlight. Of course, depending on the parasite, some of these actions could be things that their infection is driving them to do. For example, a multiple-host parasite that alternates between infecting caterpillars and infecting the birds that eat them could drive them to expose themselves to predators. Or parasites with an aquatic phase might drive them to drown themselves. But, and this is a key point, whether they are doing it to kill the parasite, or the parasite is making them do it, in either case the parasite is there!

[2] Or maybe they were. Some tachinid fly eggs look an awful lot like these. It is possible that the white objects are either eggs from the original tachinid fly that never hatched, or from a later tachinid fly that didn’t realize the caterpillar was already infested. Or, maybe empty eggshells look about the same as unhatched eggs?

[3] Fly maggots don’t really have a distinct head. One end has a mouth, but other than that it is really hard to tell the ends apart. It is quite possible that what we see here is actually the rear of the maggot, and that those circles are its breathing spiracles. It would be pretty hard to breathe inside of a caterpillar, after all.

7 Responses leave one →
  1. October 27, 2012

    I’m generally impervious to the ickies, but with this one, I have to say, “Ewwwwww!”

    But they’re beautiful flies.

  2. October 27, 2012

    Gross, but also very, very cool!

  3. October 29, 2012

    I’m with Rebecca. Fascinating and wonderful that you carried the experiment through.

  4. October 30, 2012

    I’m glad I was able to get the whole sequence, too, revolting as parts of it might be. The flies were actually astoundingly cooperative for the photographs.

    And in case anyone is wondering why I only used something as gruesome as this as a lead-up to Halloween, rather than posting it directly on the day, well, come back to see what I have queued up for tomorrow!

  5. Fred permalink
    November 8, 2012

    Your skills as a photographer a getting pretty impressive.
    note: I am using your images for a class project, hope you don’t mind.

  6. November 8, 2012

    Sure, go ahead and use them. Although, this does kind of make me wonder what kind of class project would use pictures of a caterpillar being parasitized by flies . . .

  7. jose permalink
    June 15, 2013

    the maggot that was the last one out of the caterpillar came out but first i think you are confusing its spiricales those two black dots in the rear end of the maggot with eyes those are for breathing and expelling of waste mater a camon mistake with some people great job by the way i like your pics.

Leave a Reply

Note: You can use basic XHTML in your comments. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS